Why Do We Use Biological Sex Instead of Self-Identified Gender on Our Crime Reporting Website?

Why Do We Use Biological Sex Instead of Self-Identified Gender on Our Crime Reporting Website?

Q: Why does your website list biological sex instead of gender identity in crime reports?

We use biological sex in crime data reporting to maintain consistency, reliability, and alignment with how data is currently collected and categorized by most law enforcement agencies, courts, and correctional institutions. We have a number of law enforcement agencies who utilize our data as a resource for helping with cold or unsolved cases.  This approach ensures accuracy when comparing data across jurisdictions and over time.  By storing and displaying self-identifying genders on a specific case, it may actual impede the ability for law enforcement to solve a case.

Q: Isn't using gender identity more inclusive?

Yes, using gender identity is more inclusive in many social contexts. However, crime data reporting often requires standardization based on how individuals are documented at the time of arrest, processing, or conviction. Most current legal and criminal justice systems rely on biological sex classifications, not self-identified gender, for operational and historical reasons.

Q: What is the difference between biological sex and gender identity?

  • Biological sex refers to physical and physiological attributes, such as chromosomes, hormone levels, and reproductive anatomy, typically recorded at birth as male or female.

  • Gender identity refers to a person’s internal sense of self as male, female, a blend of both, neither, or something else.

While both are important in different contexts, crime reporting and analysis traditionally focus on biological sex because that data is used in risk assessment, incarceration decisions, and statistical analysis.

Q: Are you implying that gender identity is irrelevant or unimportant?

Not at all. We recognize and respect the importance of gender identity in personal, medical, and social contexts. However, for purposes of crime reporting and statistical consistency, we follow existing standards used in criminal justice systems, which currently categorize individuals by biological sex.

Q: Will this policy change in the future?

We continuously monitor changes in criminal justice practices and reporting standards. If national or local law enforcement agencies adopt frameworks that incorporate gender identity into official records and crime statistics, we will adapt our reporting methods to reflect those changes.

Q: How do you address individuals who are transgender or nonbinary in your reporting?

Whenever possible, we aim to include contextual information in a respectful manner. However, because we report data as it is provided by official sources (e.g., police records, court documents), our classifications reflect how those institutions categorize individuals, which may not include self-identified gender unless it is legally recognized and documented.

Q: How do you ensure respectful treatment of all individuals in your reporting?

We strive to use respectful, accurate, and neutral language. We understand that discussions around gender and identity are deeply personal and sensitive, and we are committed to minimizing harm while maintaining data integrity and legal alignment.

    • Related Articles

    • Why do we use Initials and no full names?

      We use initials rather than full names in sensitive crime-related stories to protect people’s privacy and safety. This includes victims, suspects, and others connected to the events. Our goal is to share important information with the public while ...
    • What does Death by Force mean?

      CrimeSolversCentral categorizes various types of cases, including but not limited to: Homicides/Murders Self-Defense Self-Inflicted (Suicide) Accidental Primary Suspect Deceased In Litigation (Currently on Trial) Substantiated / Justified To avoid ...
    • I see an error on a case on your site. How do I let you know about it?

      If you find an error on a specific case at CrimeSolversCentral, you can easily let us know by following these steps: Go to the Case Page: Locate the specific case where you found the error. Click the 'Provide Case Information' Button: Look for the ...
    • How can I become a member of the community?

      At Crime Solvers Central, our mission is straightforward: to provide support and closure to families and friends affected by crime. To ensure we offer the most accurate and valuable insights, some of our exclusive features and data are accessible ...
    • How do I suggest a new case for CrimeSolversCentral?

      If you'd like to suggest a new case at CrimeSolversCentral, you can easily do so using the 'Submit New Case' button available on any case page. Here's how: Visit Any Case Page: Navigate to any existing case page on the CrimeSolversCentral website. ...